This article is going to be brief for now until I determine a better direction than the one I have been going in (circles). I may either edit this to focus on that or make new posts to focus on those. This is definitely still in draft form, but I’m publishing it to open it up for input since I was sitting on it for months. You may see some of my thinking-aloud notes here: feel free to comment on them if you want to hear more or if you have your own opinion on it.
The swing dance culture is an ever-evolving one and shares quite a bit with organized religion. It generally involves a knowledge of history, culture, famous historical and influential figures, etc. It has all the workings of a church. It even has scripture.
There is really no central authority (see Protestantism, but rather people tend to congregate around certain schools of thought. People tend to idolize certain people, sometimes to the point of fanaticism, emulating them.
These are all important traits, but our main topic of focus is endogamy within the swing dancing community.
Generally, people who dance Lindy Hop either dabble in or fully embrace the culture. What I am describing is the difference between two dancers who have been dancing for 5 years but one has acquired a substantially greater amount of skill and fluency than the other.
Interestingly, an immersed Lindy Hopper often feels the urge to share the joy of swing dancing with one who does not do so, or one who has been doing so for less time. This form of evangelism fortunately seems to be more successful than most other kinds because it includes an activity that many people actually find enjoyable.
Now like it or not, one of the latent functions of a church is to marry its members. Yes, I am saying that a church functions as a singles group, and I touched on it in my last post It is easy to see how this function evolved. Put people with similar values together- sparks are bound to fly. Lindy Hop is the same way. Don’t believe me? I have proof,* with special guest who I won't spoil if you haven't heard it yet.
===partnerships===
To compete effectively, dancers invariable find a partners to practice with or compete with. This may not necessarily be a platonic relationship. However, romantic relationships and dance partnerships can be entwined quite quickly. One can easily see many examples* of where dance partnerships and romantic relationships coincide- it is an extremely beneficial relationship. As romantic partners, the pair spends a lot of time together which is conducive to practice, and as practice partners, the pair spends a lot of time together practicing which is good for the romantic relationship.
However, sometimes one or both members are already engaged in romantic relationships with a third (or sometimes fourth party). This is a definite area of conflict, and I know of several examples* where people divorced over a difference in the prioritization of dancing.
A story I often hear* is that one person started dancing because his or her significant other did, and one of them stopped.
//talk about conflict of values
===the ahnold effect====
//Probably a topic for another post.
In our current society, powerful men tend to become sexually promiscuous (if they weren’t already). Or as to use a crude word, they tend to be pigs. This holds true in the dance community as well.
===funny quote for the conclusion===
With that, I will leave you with this article giving an extremely accurate and disinterested account of the man-woman relationship during dancing.
From The Ballroom To Hell, by T. A. Faulkner, 1892
"She is now in the vile embrace of the Apollo of the evening. Her head rests upon his shoulder, her face is upturned to his, her bare arm is almost around his neck, her partly nude swelling breast heaves tumultuously against his, face to face they whirl on, his limbs interwoven with hers, his strong right arm around her yielding form, he presses her to him until every curve in the contour of her body thrills with the amorous contact. Her eyes look into his, but she sees nothing; the soft music fills the room, but she hears it not; he bends her body to and fro, but she knows it not; his hot breath, tainted with strong drink, is on her hair and cheek, his lips almost fierce, intolerable lust, gloat over her, yet she does not quail. She is filled with the rapture of sin in its intensity; her spirit is inflamed with passion and lust is gratified in thought. With the last low wail the music ceases, and the dance for the night is ended, but not the evil work of the night."
*yes, I know, anecdotal evidence is not a substitute for statistical evidence, but there is virtually zero research done on this subculture
======Other side notes====
Yes, I know this subject is extremely monogamy/heterosexual-centric and doesn’t talk about poly relationships and homosexual/bisexual people. Yes, I know they exist in the dance scene and no, I’m not sure how representative it is.
Showing posts with label endogamy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label endogamy. Show all posts
Saturday, July 23, 2011
Thursday, March 31, 2011
Religion, Part 1
Religion is such a critical topic I wish to start off addressing it. I understand this may seem like a bad idea to start off on as it is an extremely touchy subject- one that people should avoid in day to day conversation. However, it is extremely important to us- especially of our country nonetheless. In fact, at the time of this writing, the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life released a report that 83% of Americans subscribe to organized religion. I bring up this topic not because I mean to espouse or detract from religion, but that I wish to describe its social structures and why they were created, and how they are present in similar social structures. For the sake of brevity and to minimize the chance of mistakes, I will use examples from the religions I am most familiar with.
Religions are far more complex systems than merely a belief. Religious socialization endows a set of values, morals, and code of conduct onto its members. One may argue that these rules are very burdensome, but in cases like nomadic Israel, all the rules that Mosaic law imposed upon the people were critical to their survival.
One example that comes up (at least in my life frequently) is kosher food. It seems to be quite troublesome to follow such strict diet regulations, but take a look at the clean and unclean rules that the Israelites had regarding animals. A brief look would reveal that in general, only herbivores were eaten, which minimizes the chance that the animals would consume other unclean things. Scavengers like pigs and birds of prey were expressly forbidden (and are also considered haraam in Islamic law). Hopefully, I need not elaborate on the benefits of abstaining from such food in those days. One can argue also that not eating pork, shellfish, and such can also lead to less risk of food allergies, as well as lower cholesterol and fat, something we care about more these days than at that time (probably for the reason that we are eating them!). Such rules like these assist in the physical survival of the group but there were also some codified standards of behavior and that minimized strife within the group. I could explain this much further, but perhaps for another time.
Not only must a religion have these codes to maintain cohesion and identity, a religion must contend with intersecting cultures. A religion must be able to redefine itself to be relevant in the face of majority groups, or it may be rejected in favor of new value systems.
This brings us to our next discussion: Many religions have codes regarding endogamy, or the selection of mates within a group. The principal benefit of endogamy to a religion is the creation of further and deeper ties in the group, particularly with that of sacraments and customs associated with mate selection. I believe the codifying of this value is almost moot point, but a value beneficial to the religion nonetheless. Let me explain. First, I will concede that by the codifying the choice of partners within the group, additional moral feedback can be given by other members in the group, thus presenting additional barriers to departure from the group. In other words, having this manifest rule stigmatizes the behavior of intermarriage outside of the religious group, garnering criticism from peers, and thus discouraging the behavior.
That aside, if the pursuit of religion occupies a significant portion of one's life, it is difficult to depart from the lifestyle one is accustomed to. If there was conflict between their religion and their partner(s), ultimately a decision must be made, and the goats are parted from the lambs, so to speak. One who is not firmly rooted within that lifestyle will leave for another. Take for example, according to US census data, from 1945 to 1995, the intermarriage of Jews with non-Jews increased from 1 in 10 to 1 in 2, and the percentage of Jews in America has dropped from 4 to 2%. This should be no surprise to anyone: the melting pot in this instance means the erosion of the Jewish culture by assimilation into our modern day cultures. In this light, we should marvel that that we can even find this culture thousands of years later- a testament to the incredible power of religion as a cultural preservation mechanism.
In Part 2, we will discuss modern day social phenomena with great resemblances to religious cultures.
Religions are far more complex systems than merely a belief. Religious socialization endows a set of values, morals, and code of conduct onto its members. One may argue that these rules are very burdensome, but in cases like nomadic Israel, all the rules that Mosaic law imposed upon the people were critical to their survival.
One example that comes up (at least in my life frequently) is kosher food. It seems to be quite troublesome to follow such strict diet regulations, but take a look at the clean and unclean rules that the Israelites had regarding animals. A brief look would reveal that in general, only herbivores were eaten, which minimizes the chance that the animals would consume other unclean things. Scavengers like pigs and birds of prey were expressly forbidden (and are also considered haraam in Islamic law). Hopefully, I need not elaborate on the benefits of abstaining from such food in those days. One can argue also that not eating pork, shellfish, and such can also lead to less risk of food allergies, as well as lower cholesterol and fat, something we care about more these days than at that time (probably for the reason that we are eating them!). Such rules like these assist in the physical survival of the group but there were also some codified standards of behavior and that minimized strife within the group. I could explain this much further, but perhaps for another time.
Not only must a religion have these codes to maintain cohesion and identity, a religion must contend with intersecting cultures. A religion must be able to redefine itself to be relevant in the face of majority groups, or it may be rejected in favor of new value systems.
This brings us to our next discussion: Many religions have codes regarding endogamy, or the selection of mates within a group. The principal benefit of endogamy to a religion is the creation of further and deeper ties in the group, particularly with that of sacraments and customs associated with mate selection. I believe the codifying of this value is almost moot point, but a value beneficial to the religion nonetheless. Let me explain. First, I will concede that by the codifying the choice of partners within the group, additional moral feedback can be given by other members in the group, thus presenting additional barriers to departure from the group. In other words, having this manifest rule stigmatizes the behavior of intermarriage outside of the religious group, garnering criticism from peers, and thus discouraging the behavior.
That aside, if the pursuit of religion occupies a significant portion of one's life, it is difficult to depart from the lifestyle one is accustomed to. If there was conflict between their religion and their partner(s), ultimately a decision must be made, and the goats are parted from the lambs, so to speak. One who is not firmly rooted within that lifestyle will leave for another. Take for example, according to US census data, from 1945 to 1995, the intermarriage of Jews with non-Jews increased from 1 in 10 to 1 in 2, and the percentage of Jews in America has dropped from 4 to 2%. This should be no surprise to anyone: the melting pot in this instance means the erosion of the Jewish culture by assimilation into our modern day cultures. In this light, we should marvel that that we can even find this culture thousands of years later- a testament to the incredible power of religion as a cultural preservation mechanism.
In Part 2, we will discuss modern day social phenomena with great resemblances to religious cultures.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)